Two Common HPLC Problems and their Causes (Sudden changes to either the HPLC Backpressure or Peak Shape)

   Let's take a quick look at two different problems which you may encounter when operating an HPLC system. We start with the basic observation and then look at the most likely causes so we can begin the troubleshooting process and repair the problem. An automated HPLC system's flow path typically consists of: The Solvent Pickup Filters (in the mobile phase reservoirs); The Pump(s); AutoSampler; AutoInjector; Column and one or more Detectors.*You should have a good understanding of this flow path before you proceed to diagnose the problem(s).

 *A gradual increase of pressure for the same method over time is often due to column fouling or a dirty inlet frit (e.g. PTFE frit). This article specifically focuses on the causes of a sudden change, not a slow change over time.

   Sudden System Back Pressure Changes: We will assume that you have been running the same method for some time or at least several times without a problem and then suddenly notice that the back pressure has changed from what is normally seen. The problem must lie within the flow path of the system.

   Excessive High Pressure: Typical reasons for this are:

1.      A fouled or plugged column;
2.      Wrong flow rate (higher than normal);
3.      Inlet frit/filter plugged or restricted;
4.      Plugged line;
5.      Wrong mobile phase composition.

   Large Drop in Pressure: Typical reasons for this are:

1.      A leak at a fitting, column or line (Number one reason);
2.      Wrong flow rate (lower than normal);
3.      Wrong mobile phase composition. 

• Start by checking the method parameters to insure that they have not changed (i.e. flow rate, mobile phase composition). Check for leaks or plugs. If the column is suspect, replace it with a zero dead volume union (ZDU) and restrictor and flush the system. Replace the column with a new one or wash the current column according to the column manufacturer's guidelines.

   Sudden Peak Shape Changes: We will again assume that you have been running the same method for some time or at least several times without a problem and then suddenly notice that the peak shape of one or all of the peaks has changed from what is normally seen. *The key thing to keep in mind is that the change occurs all of a sudden, not because of poor initial method development.

   Typical reasons for this are:

1.      Tailing or Split Peaks: Sample overload, change in flow rate, mobile phase composition (e.g. composition or pH), void formation, dirty frit, injection solvent too strong or a fouled column.
2.      Fronting: Commonly seen when overloading sample on column.
3.      Ghost Peaks: Usually due to a contaminated mobile phase, contaminated sample vial or contaminated injector (e.g. rotor seal).
4.      Broad Peaks: Large sample injection volumes or extra column volume (bad connections with the system or tubing) are usually to blame. Try reducing the injection volume by a factor of 10 and see if the problem goes away. You may also want to wash the column as it may be fouled with sample.

   These are just two common problems we see when using HPLC systems. Note that a dirty or fouled column can cause many of these problems so take care of your columns and wash and test them regularly to insure they are in compliance. There are many other commonly seen problems besides these. If you would like to see a specific problem featured on this blog, then please send me a request.



  

HPLC Maintenance & Repair Parts To Have on Hand for HPLC Systems

HPLC (UHPLC) systems are complex instruments which require periodic inspection, cleaning and maintenance. These tasks are critical to maintain the performance, reliability and accuracy of the instrument. If you have not done so already, I strongly recommend that you create formal standard operating procedures (SOP's) which address: (1) The frequency of when routine and non-routine maintenance procedures should be performed; (2) The types of maintenance and/or repair procedures used (e.g. piston seal replacement, A/I rotary valve seal replacement); (3) The exact step-by-step procedure to follow in performing these tasks and (4) The Performance Verification or Qualification steps and procedures which are to be performed to verify that any repairs made have been done correctly. *An instrument log book should be employed to document these procedures over time.

Periodic "General Maintenance" of the HPLC is one type of service procedure which should be scheduled at a set frequency (Example: Every 6 months) and will serve to provide a time to clean, inspect and repair/replace any parts which are worn due to normal use. Such routine HPLC maintenance is often referred to as a basic "Preventative Maintenance" service (or "PM Service"). Spare parts common to your HPLC system(s) should be on hand to perform these scheduled maintenance procedures as part of a normal PM service.

Here is a list of common parts that should be on hand for a "typical" HPLC system used in a pharmaceutical laboratory. Please consult the appropriate manufacture's product literature to determine the correct parts needed for your own HPLC system. This list is presented as a general guideline only:

• Capillary tubing, fittings (nuts and ferrules): Assorted fittings, usually made of 316 Stainless Steel, but could be made of polymeric materials. Always have spare precut and polished chromatography tubing of appropriate I.D. and lengths for use with your HPLC available at all times. Insure that the nuts and ferrules used are appropriate for your brand of HPLC system and the columns used as different manufacturers have different specifications for their fittings and ferrules. Many types are not interchangeable.

• Detector Lamps: At least one spare bulb of a type designed for your specific detector should be on hand. Note that some detectors use multiple lamps so you may need to have more than one type available for each detector. Some lamp bulb types (e.g. tungsten) can be safely stored and last for several years while other types, such as Deuterium bulbs, loose substantial energy after as little as 6 months. If you have several detectors of the exact same design, then there is often no need to stock multiple replacement bulbs for each one. Instead, stock enough bulbs to service one detector as it is unlikely you would see failure of more than one detector on the same day (an exception to this guideline is if you perform PM services on all of the instruments at the same time, then you may want to have multiple bulbs available).

• Pump Pistons: One set of spare new pistons should be kept on hand for each pump module. As with lamp bulbs, if you have several identical pumps, then there is often no need to stock multiple sets of pistons for each one. Stock only as many as you expect to use in one year. Clean and inspect the pistons during each PM for any signs of scratches or surface abrasions. Under routine use, pistons should only require general cleaning and last a long time before replacement is required (> 1 year). Mobile phases which contain high concentrations of salt buffers often accelerate this wear requiring more frequent replacement. *Always install new piston seals when replacing pistons.

• Pump Piston Seals: At least one set of spare new piston seals should be on hand for each pump module. Seals wear out more frequently than pistons. You should go through two or more sets of piston seals before you need to replace the pistons. If the piston seals leak, inspect the pistons for wear (replace with new ones or clean and reuse) and install new piston seals. Mobile phases which contain high concentrations of salt buffers often accelerate this wear.

• Solvent Pickup Filters: These are the large particle filters which sit inside your solvent or mobile phase bottles. They are often made from stainless steel or sintered glass with porous inlets (~10 to 30 micron) and can clog or become fouled over time (esp. when used with aqueous buffers). In some cases these can be cleaned using sonication (not sintered glass filters, only steel or polymeric!). Note: Sometimes it is most cost effective to replace them with new filters then clean and re-use them.

• Inline Frits/Filters: You may have an inline filter placed after your PUMP head, but before the column inlet to collect any remaining particulate matter. These filters can extend the lifetime of the entire HPLC system (esp. the A/S, A/I and Column), but will only do so if changed on a regular basis. Some manufacturers incorporate this type of filter into the design of their pump modules. An example of this can be found on the HP/Agilent brand model 1050, 1100 and/or 1200-series pumps. These have an inexpensive 10 micron PTFE frit installed in the outlet valve of the pump. This filter catches all of the normally occurring piston seal debris and larger mobile phase particles and should be changed every month. Other pre-filters are installed in cartridges just before the column inlet. These often overlooked pre-filters filters must be replaced about once each month to do their job properly. Keep plenty of spare filters on hand.

• Auto-injector Rotary Valve Seals: If you have an auto-injector, then a high pressure valve is probably used to switch the sample into the flow path for analysis. This valve will have one or more parts which require regular inspection, cleaning and periodic replacement. Mobile phases which contain high concentrations of salt buffers often accelerate this wear. The valve rotor seal is the most common part which requires replacement.

• Auto-Sampler Needle: A needle should last a very long time, but depending on the frequency of use and type of vial septa encountered it can require replacement at regular intervals. A good general guideline would be to keep one spare needle on hand for every 2-4 systems.

• Auto-Sampler Needle Seat: The needle seat often requires more frequent replacement than the needle due to repeated mechanical wear. A good general guideline would be to keep one spare needle seat on hand for each system.

• UV/VIS Detector Flow Cell: While not actually a required PM spare part, this one is worthwhile to have. If you employ a UV/VIS flow cell, then I always suggest you keep one dedicated spare flow cell on hand which matches the size and volume of the type you use in your instrument. A spare flow cell can prove to be very valuable as a troubleshooting tool if you believe that you have contaminated or clogged your current flow cell. A quick swap can answer the question and get you back to work quickly saving hours or days of lost time. *Note: This extra flow cell should be kept separate from all instruments for use as a tested spare only and not used for regular analysis.

If you have suggestions for other types of common HPLC spares to add to the list or to have on hand, then please let me know.

What type of Water Should I use for HPLC, UHPLC or LC/MS Analysis?

Water is one of the most common solvents used in reversed phase chromatography. HPLC and LC/MS work demands ultra pure quality water be used in all applications which call for it as part of the method. Special types of HPLC analysis, such as amino acid analysis and ion chromatography, demand fresh ultra high quality water be used or artifact peaks may result. Poor quality or low grades of water may lead to "ghost peaks", baseline instability, high background noise or signals, contamination of columns and an inability to obtain reproducible results. Use the freshest and highest purity of water for best results.

A good starting point for describing the type of water suited to liquid chromatography applications is to look at the specification for ASTM Type 1 Reagent grade water. We often exceed this requirement for chromatography applications as several unspecified items such as nitrates and other chemicals present may have a negative effect on our analysis methods.

How does the grade of water affect our chromatography? The grade specified often dictates the amount of organics, bacteria, particulate, residues and overall absorbance the water will have. For example.

(1) Organics: High levels of T.O.C. can accumulate on the particles, inside the pores, or bind to active sites on the support inside the column causing a loss of resolution or sensitivity. *Lower T.O.C. levels are desirable.

(2) Bacteria: Microorganisms can contaminate the buffer solutions used causing ghost peaks, column fouling and the release of additional foreign organic matter into the system. This can result in clogs, ghost peaks, poor reproducibility or loss of resolution and/or sensitivity. *The water should be filtered through a 0.2 micron filter before use. Refrigerate solutions for no more than 3 days to slow growth, then dispose of the solutions.

(3) UV absorbance: High background or interfering ions which absorb can raise the baseline and noise levels seen, decreasing the total dynamic range. *Again, the lowest values, esp. at 200nm, are desirable.

A few of the general requirements for HPLC grade ultrapure Type 1 water can be stated as follows:

   Resistivity :         > 18 MΩ•cm at 25.0 C
   T.O.C. :              < 5 ppb
   UV cutoff :          190nm (as low in absorbance as possible!)
   Filtered :             0.2 micron Filter

*Some suppliers will also specify residue after evaporation (usually < 2 ppm); Trace metal analysis; Optical properties at specified wavelengths and other information. If purchasing by the bottle, request a copy of the lot certification sheet for the water so you can compare the measured values to other products.

Generating your own in-house, reverse osmosis (RO) ultra pure water from potable tap water is one of the best ways to insure you have high quality water for your LC methods. These systems pre-filter the water to remove large particulates then typically use UV lamps and/or multiple resin cartridges to remove the maximum amount of T.O.C.'s from the water plus many trace metals before finally filtering the water through a 0.2 micron membrane as a final polishing step. Various types of systems can be purchased, but for HPLC or LC-MS applications, it is critical that you select a system that provides ultra pure water suitable for your applications. Periodic maintenance of the filter cartridges and monitoring of the main water supply source is critical to their operation (some "tap" water sources may require pre-treatement). *"Water On Demand" systems such as these provide fresh clean water on demand so there is no need to be concerned with storage issues. A number of different vendors offer these lab grade systems for HPLC and LC/MS applications and you can contact them (e.g. Millipore/Sigma Milli-Q® brand) to determine which system will provide you with the volume and quality of water which is appropriate for your application(s).

If you do not have access to an in-house reverse osmosis system, then purchasing HPLC or LC/MS grade water in glass bottles may be another option. A hint, before opening and using them,  clean the outside of bottles of all dust. Date the bottles when you first open them. Bacteria will start to grow once the bottle has been opened. The glass will also slowly leach ions (i.e. Sodium) over time into the water so it is best to use the water quickly.

Never underestimate how the quality of the water you use to perform chromatography can change the results seen in your methods. Water quality is just as critical as any other component in your system so be sure and take the time to monitor it just like you do to any other part of the system.

Method Development Hint: Use your HPLC Diode Array Detector (DAD or PDA) as a Spectrophotometer

One of the many useful features of a UV/VIS scanning diode array detector is that it can be employed in flow injection mode to scan a sample and provide you with some useful data about the absorbance characteristics of the sample (which probably contains a mixture of components). Unlike a spectrophotometer, you only need about 1 ul of sample instead of a 1ml cuvette and only 15-20 seconds of time to gather the data.

Why do this? I use this feature often when I receive a new and unfamiliar sample for method development. I set up the detector to scan and store all wavelengths, in steps of 2nm, from 210nm to 450nm and inject the sample in flow injection mode (that means no-column is present and I easily do this using the By-Pass position on my column selector). In a very short amount of time I can view the resulting spectra of the sample which aids me in selecting the initial discreet wavelengths to monitor. For example: If I notice that the sample shows some absorbance at 410nm using the flow injection run, then notice while developing the analysis method that none of the peaks seen show absorbance near 410nm, then I can assume that I may still have some components retained on the column.

Setup Hints:
(1) For this to work well, you should have a high performance, low volume switching valve or automated column selection system (e.g. The LC Spiderling Column Selection System) installed so you can easily by-pass your column (otherwise, remove your column and place a high pressure, low volume union in its place).
(2) Set the diode array detector to a high sampling rate because the sample is going to fly through the flow cell quickly. Use a sampling rate that is faster than you would use if a column was there to disperse the sample and slow down the peaks.
(3) Choose a wide range of wavelengths to scan and store. If the sample appears colorless to the eye in solution and I am running in a UV transparent solvent such as acetonitrile, then I often use a range of 210 to 450nm.