Cannabis, Cannabinoid (Hemp, THC, CBD, CBN, Marijuana) HPLC Analysis and Testing, Areas for Improvement [*Updated 8/2021]

Over the past few years we have observed an exponential growth in the number of state-level, legal businesses (in the USA) who offer Cannabis Analysis (e.g. Potency Analysis or Profiles) and/or related businesses such as Hemp Oil Extraction. Most related products which incorporate Marijuana, CBD, THC, Cannabinoids, Terpenes and/or other related compounds require formal analytical laboratory testing which should follow good laboratory practices. This article is targeted to help many of the people involved in this new analysis business (or anyone using chromatography as the analytical technique of choice for the same goals).

As a professional chromatography consultant, I have seen a large increase in the number of requests for my services to this new market. Most of these new businesses have questions about obtaining professional training, correct analysis procedures, improving reproducibility, documentation, optimizing method development, how to receive professional training in maintenance of the HPLC system(s) and need hands-on help to optimize the procedures used. Many users are not achieving acceptable results and need help finding out why. They want to know where they can take a class to learn HPLC method development and how to perform the required tests. 

These new businesses would benefit greatly from professional guidance EARLY in their setup and establishment, to improve the internal methods and procedures of analysis used. Time spent on the "front-end" of any process is always time spent wisely (in this context, knowledge and practical experience = confidence). A chromatography professional can quickly identify areas which may need improvement and/or suggest changes that can directly improve your company's accuracy, reproducibility, increase efficiency and of course, impact your bottom-line too. Focus is placed on the exact areas that will benefit you (rather than wasting time with non-targeted approaches, sales biased classes and trial-and-error approaches). 

• Please note that there are NO SCIENTIFICALLY LEGITIMATE ONE DAY, ONE WEEK or ONE MONTH LONG TRAINING CLASSES THAT CAN TEACH YOU HOW TO PERFORM HPLC METHOD DEVELOPMENT or ANALYSIS. NONE AT ALL. Most types of "Certification" offered are completely without scientific merit or value. The training needed takes many years of hands-on experience, in an industrial laboratory (not a school), to acquire just a basic level of proficiency (*Emphasis on 'Basic", not intermediate or expert). Be very cautious of anyone who claims to be able to provide you with all the training you need in a short time period.
  

Generating accurate and reproducible analytical data, esp. with HPLC, SFC or GC requires a great deal of knowledge, formal training and practical hands-on experience (not something which is taught at most university or school programs). These complex techniques require years of bench time and professional hands-on experience to learn). Shipping or selling products which contain unacceptable levels of impurities or which do not meet basic testing or regulatory qualifications could pose a health and/or liability risk. Hire people who have the needed training from industry before setting up the laboratory.

It has been my professional experience that some of the most common training areas that client's would benefit from are: GLP (Good Laboratory Practices/Procedures and SOPs) and additional instrument operational training to demonstrate proficiency in analytical chromatography. Address these areas early on and continuously update them to reduce errors and improve results. Training should continue on a regular basis to gain experience.
 
While each confidential consultation visit I have with a client may show different key issues which need to be addressed, many labs can start to improve their analytical results by addressing and improving how they address:

1. Documentation: Laboratory methods and sample analysis must be conducted using clearly written documentation. This should initially include having Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) in place for all methods, procedures, qualification, verification and tests used. They should include SOPs, Document Control and Policy documents which also address: Training, Calibration, Maintenance, Frequency of the same, Mobile phase preparation, pH measurement, use of the balance and so on... I find that it is best to create an initial SOP Template to insure document uniformity (i.e. include such fields as: Business Name, SOP #, review/approval date(s)/names, Rev #, materials & tools needed, purpose, procedure steps, pass/fail definitions... plus any needed supporting documents).
2. Sample Preparation Methods: Be sure to document, test, review / standardize specific sample preparation methods, for each sample type. Variations in: temperature, extraction solvent or the solution(s) dissolved in, homogenization or grinding methods, mixing, times used, glass or plastic containers used may result in significant variation of the final reported results.
3. Correct Poor Reproducibility and/or Baseline Instability Issues: In chromatography analysis, if the method(s) used are not stable and reproducible, every time they are run, then little to no scientific value can be obtained from them. Methods used must follow basic good chromatography fundamentals and meet basic guidelines. Baseline noise or instability may directly impact integration results (which directly impacts reported results). Instrumentation must be operated in clean, climate controlled rooms. Failure to reproduce a result within acceptable limits (these will vary per method type) will invalidate the method used. Make sure that SOP's are followed, mobile phase solutions are made fresh each day (do not pre-mix solutions with acids and let them sit for several days before use; do not "top off" bottles), solutions should be degassed, HPLC columns are properly washed and re-equilibrated before each analysis, instruments are maintained (per a SOP) and serviced on a regular basis. 
4. Develop HPLC methods that follow good chromatography fundamentals: Retain, separate and resolve ALL peaks. Insure peak K primes are 2.0 or higher. If you have co-eluted peaks in your method, then method development is not finished. If you have ghost peaks or changing retention times, then you need to stop running samples and find out why. Be careful whose method(s) you use. A method that is "Validated" may not be scientifically valid method to use. Have the method checked by an experienced chromatographer.
   
5. Continuous Training is Required to become Proficient: To be proficient, at a basic level in chromatography, takes most chromatographers several years working in an industrial environment to gain practical hands-on time. That assumes that they have had professional training outside of college, in an industrial lab, and can demonstrate an understanding of the fundamentals of good chromatography. Note, that method development skills require a much higher level of understanding and hands-on training to acquire the needed skill set. Make sure your scientists have the needed level of training to operate, run analysis methods and troubleshoot any issues that come up (and issues will come-up, even under ideal conditions). Please do not make the mistake of thinking they will "figure it out" on their own. Hire people who already have several years of industrial chromatography experience, then provide them with additional training opportunities to advance their skills in the application areas that your business needs.  Get them help NOW, you will save money and time, plus get back on track moving forward with your project.
   

If you want to surpass your competitors and provide clients with the most accurate data, then investing in your employees professional knowledge and hands-on technical training is the fastest route to do so. This is an experience based technique where decades of practical knowledge are needed to improve your skill set. A professional can quickly provide you with practical information and show you techniques that will help you move forward. 1-2 days of on-site training often translates to nearly one years worth of knowledge. What is one-years worth of lost time worth to you?
  
Additional Resources:

• Modern HPLC Method Development Tips (PART I): 
• Modern HPLC Method Development Tips (PART II):
• EXPERT CANNABINOID HPLC Training and CONSULTING SERVICES: 

Common pKa Values for ACIDS & BASES used in HPLC and LC/MS Method Development

pKa (25°C)                              ACID

0.3                                           Trifluoroacetic acid

2.15                                          Phosphoric acid (pK#1)

3.13                                          Citric acid (pK#1)

3.75                                          Formic acid

4.76                                          Acetic acid

4.76                                          Citric acid (pK#2)

4.86                                          Propionic acid

6.35                                          Carbonic acid (pK#1)

6.40                                          Citric acid (pK#3)

7.20                                          Phosphoric acid (pK#2)

8.06                                          Tris

9.23                                          Boric acid

9.25                                          Ammonia

9.78                                          Glycine (pK#2)

10.33                                        Carbonic acid (pK#2)

10.72                                        Triethylamine

11.27                                        Pyrrolidine

12.33                                        Phosphoric acid (pK#3)

Notes: (1) This is a general list of commonly used acids & bases for chromatography applications and not meant to be a comprehensive list of all values. (2) TFA is an overused and very strong acid for many chromatography applications. It also has strong ion pairing properties and can result in high UV noise, vacuum degasser and/or MS contamination. If you must use it, try and use the lowest concentration which results in the desired pH. Example: 0.1 % TFA ~ pH 2.0, 0.02% TFA ~ pH 2.7. (3) Formic acid is a popular alternative to TFA for many applications, esp LC/MS. (4) Not all acids/bases provide "buffering" on their own.

Reference: CRC Handbook of Chemistry & Physics.

An Often Ignored HPLC & LC/MS Contamination Source. Did you check your Vacuum Degasser?

The introduction of electronic vacuum degassing / degasser modules to the liquid chromatography industry a few decades ago has introduced several new problems which were unknown years ago when we sparged our mobile phase solutions with high-purity helium gas. One of these problems relates to how the electronic vacuum degassing modules themselves can contribute to contaminating your HPLC or LC-MS system.

Before using an HPLC vacuum degasser module, please review all of the information and advice supplied by the manufacturer of your specific degassing module. The composition of the internal degassing tubing has changed a great deal over the past decades resulting in increased degassing efficiency, but also changes in mobile phase chemical compatibility. Some popular solvents may be incompatible with some models in your lab. Make sure you know exactly which types of vacuum chambers and plastics are used in your specific instrument(s). Degassing modules must be operated, cleaned and maintained the same as your other important instruments. When they are not operating properly and/or are contaminated, they should be serviced as soon as possible or risk further contamination and damage to your system ($$$).

•  Link to a pdf document with pictures showing common contamination and damage observed while inspecting HPLC Vacuum degasser modules for our clients. Have you had your HPLC vacuum degasser(s) professionally evaluated for damage? [ https://www.chiralizer.com/examples_of_degasser_contamination.pdf ].
  

In a previous post ["Inline HPLC Degassing Modules"] we discussed the convenience that these devices have brought to our laboratories, but also the extra training requirements (such as cleaning and flushing the vacuum channels every day and routine servicing every 2 to 5 years) which must be undertaken to use them successfully. When the operational guidelines for the use of these products are ignored, these devices can contribute to the contamination of your HPLC and /or LC-MS system. The internal wettable surfaces of each degassing chamber contain plastics (examples of plastic used: Teflon, Teflon AF, Tefzel and/or Peek are the most common types of used). To effectively remove gas from the mobile phase, the liquid must pass through plastic tubing (or across membranes) placed in a vacuum, for a period of time which is long enough to allow a portion of the dissolved gas in the mobile phase to diffuse through the degassing tubing/membrane and out the exhaust port of the degassing chamber. The degassing tubing (most use tubing) should have the maximum chemical compatibility possible while allowing it to also be porous enough for the gas alone to diffuse through the walls of the tubing under vacuum. These requirements usually result in some type of fluoropolymer tubing (Variants of Teflon or Teflon AF) being used as they have broad chemical compatibility plus can be formed with controlled pore sizes for the effective removal of gas, not liquid, through the tubing walls. However, there are exceptions to this and the plastic(s) used may NOT be chemically compatible with all liquids used in chromatography applications. Depending on the plastic degassing tubing used, the tubing may swell, fail or even dissolve into the mobile phase solution! Be sure and check the chemical compatibility chart offered by the degassing module manufacturer for compatibility with your mobile phase and ALL additives used before using the instrument. Some examples of incompatible chemicals on the lists of many instrument vendors include: THF, Chloroform, DCM, strong acids or bases, Hexanes and Sodium Azide. Use of incompatible solvents or additives may result in complete failure of the degasser module plus contamination of the entire instrument flow path. We have seen many degasser systems which were used with (or stored in, w/o proper flushing) strong acids show corrosion of the metal parts inside the chambers (SS fittings and connectors) forming piles of rust and salts which were carried through the vacuum system resulting in damage to the system and flow path contamination. *Please do not risk it. Be aware of which chemicals may pose a risk with your system. For example: The use of many fluorinated solvents may dissolve most types of tubing when Teflon AF is used for degassing.

• Note: We have seen an increase in the use of various perfluorinated solvents, esp with LC/MS systems. This has resulted in severe degasser damage plus MS source contamination (e.g. HFIP and Ethoxynonafluorobutane). Most perfluorinated solvents are not compatible with vacuum chambers which contain Teflon AF. They may dissolve the degassing tubing, resulting in the destruction of the degasser chambers and contamination of the vacuum system and mobile phase (IOW: the complete HPLC system flow path). Additionally, we commonly see ion-pairing reagents such as TFA and TBA "sticking" to the plastic used in these modules causing a leaching of material over long periods of time (again, most obvious on an MS system where you can "detect" it in the background signal). These ion-pairing agents must be thoroughly flushed out of the flow path to reduce contaminating the entire system over time. *A strong wash solution with a little acid (formic) alternated with a wash containing some base (ammonium) often helps in this regard. Wash cycles of over 12 hours are often needed to remove these compounds and see improvement (It may take much longer...). In some cases we must replace some or all of the internal parts of the degassing module to eliminate the contamination. Always remove any HPLC column from the flow path (to avoid re-contaminating again) and replace with a new one, once the contamination has been removed. It is for this reason that we should avoid the use of strong ion-pairing reagents in any LC/MS system, as they often contribute to very high background signals and long term contamination. *Helium sparging should be considered for such applications.

Reversed phase HPLC applications which use highly aqueous mobile phases may under some circumstances result in high rates of pervaporation of the water vapor into the degasser module resulting in condensation of the water into the vacuum system (Unlike the older Teflon material used, the newer Teflon AF formula is more permeable to water vapor). Once liquid enters the vacuum pump, severe damage has already occurred and failure of the vacuum system soon follows. *If you ever notice liquid exiting through the vac pump's exhaust port, turn off the HPLC system and have the degasser module professionally serviced. 

Another common problem seen when aqueous solutions are used in an in-line vacuum degasser are that of algae and bacterial growth. Most often observed in systems left unused for a period of time or which are not periodically flushed out with organic solvents. Growth inside the low pressure tubing and even inside the vacuum chambers has been known to contaminate the entire flow path of an HPLC system. Replacement of the tubing and internal chambers usually resolves the problem.

Buffers / Additives: Just as with the rest of your HPLC system, any buffer salts, acid, bases or additives which are left in the system (even overnight) can damage it. This is true of the vacuum degasser module too. Please be sure to flush all of the vacuum degassing chambers of any salts or buffers when not in use.

For normal phase applications, high concentrations of n-Hexane may cause contamination or damage to a degasser attached to an HPLC or LC/MS system. Some types of degassers are not compatible with Hexane. The ultra high evaporation rate of hexane coupled to the advanced materials found in the degassing tubing or membranes may result in the hexane condensing on the outside of the internal degassing tubing of the degasser and then aspirated into the vacuum system (causing damage). The contaminants are then transported back through the tubing walls into the solvent stream (your mobile phase).

If your HPLC's vacuum degasser fails to achieve vacuum, has liquid exiting the vacuum pump exhaust port (or exhaust tubing) or shows an error (e.g. Leak Error, High RPM, makes loud noise, a Yellow or Red light on an HP/Agilent system or "Degasser Hardware Fault" / "Degasser High Leak Rate" messages often seen on Waters brand systems), then your entire HPLC system may be out-of-compliance - because the degasser is broken. Have the vacuum degasser professionally cleaned and repaired so you can put the system back online. Do not assume that only the vacuum pump has failed, as replacement of the pump alone often results in failure of the replacement pump soon after (due to contamination and other problems incorrectly diagnosed). The true cause of the failure must be correctly diagnosed and repaired first, and this is something best left to professionals.

Our professional HPLC degasser repair shop receives many types of degasser modules with leaking or ruptured vacuum chambers. These directly contribute to mobile phase contamination as any seal failure in these normally "dry" systems results in liquid contaminating the vacuum system which in-turn sends contaminated liquid and vapors back into the HPLC mobile phase stream. *Note: If you are using your HPLC degasser with Mass Spec detector, then the resulting mobile phase contamination may contaminate not just your column, but MS source too (costing a great deal of money to decontaminate). Please, at the first sign of trouble, have the degasser professionally diagnosed, cleaned and repaired. For more information on having your degasser professionally diagnosed and repaired with fast turnaround at a fraction of the price charged by most instrument vendors, please refer to this link: "HPLC Degasser Repair Service" [ http://www.chiralizer.com/hplc-degasser-repair.html ]