HPLC Baseline Stabilization Tips for Refractive Index Detectors (RI or RID)

If you use refractive index detection (RID) for your HPLC samples, then you are already familiar with the very long equilibration periods needed to stabilize the system and associated baseline drift. Initial equilibration can take several hours. In fact, re-equilibration takes far longer to achieve with this detection mode than most others (i.e. UV/VIS, FLUOR, EC). While there is no quick cure for these delays, there are a number of things that you may be able to do to minimize or reduce these wait times. Here are a few to consider.

• ROOM TEMPERATURE: Locate the RID in a quiet, stable location. If the room temperature in which your HPLC system with RID system is located fluctuates by even one degree C, that can effect the stabilization of the system. The ideal room to use RID will be away from any windows, drafts, doorways, direct sunlight and HVAC vents or ducts. It should be located in a quiet area away from people walking by it. All of these things can contribute to temperature instability, which is what you want to avoid.

• INSULATION of HPLC CAPILLARY LINES: All of those stainless steel capillary lines leading from your column outlet to the RID's flow cell are loosing heat to the surrounding air (cooling). To reduce this thermal effect, insulate any metal lines with plastic tubing to reduce the heat loss. Most any type of laboratory grade, thick walled plastic tubing can be used. Pass the SS tubing through the plastic insulated tubing or use a section of split-tubing to cover it. Cover as much of the exposed tubing as possible, right up to the fittings. - Note: Sometime the HPLC system's solvent bottles may be subjected to varying temperature changes too. In these cases you can wrap the bottles with an appropriate insulating material to reduce the effects.

• FLOW CELL TEMPERATURE: Modern RID units have a heated flow cell with thermostat to control the temperature of the flow cell. This helps stabilize the temperature inside the flow cell as well as minimize the unintended effect that the heat given off by the RID's electronics has on the temperature inside the flow cell. If the flow cell temperature does not stabilize, then the baseline will drift in response to it. For most methods, select a flow cell temperature which is at least 10 degrees C above ambient (since most of these units can heat only, not cool). Factor in any column temperature used too. If you are maintaining your column at 40C, then try to maintain your flow cell at the same temperature to minimize any differences. Feel free to experiment to find the best temperature for your flow cell. Try different temperatures (in 5 degree C intervals), wait for the system to fully equilibrate, then measure the baseline S/N ratio. You may find best results using different column and flow cell temperatures. Sometimes the room temperature effect can be countered by using an optimized flow cell temperature (higher or lower). Always factor in your mobile phase boiling point (b.p.) into your method and keep the column and flow cell temperatures well below the b.p.

• DEGASSING / DECREASING DISSOLVED OXYGEN: Reduce and stabilize the amount of dissolved gas inside the mobile phase and you may achieve faster equilibration times with a RID. You do not need to remove all the dissolved gas (in fact, a reduction of 50% is often enough). The amount of dissolved gas inside the mobile phase effects the measured refractive index. As it changes, so does your baseline. High percentages of mobile phase dissolved gas = lower RI; Less dissolved gas = higher RI. Now water holds less dissolved gas than non-polar organic solvents (e.g. THF) so this effect is more pronounced when you are running non-aqueous GPC separations, but maintaining a stable dissolved gas level for all mobile phase types is important to reduce baseline drift. Stability is our goal. Continuous degassing of the mobile phase either through sparging with high purity helium gas (best for non-aqueous separations) OR using an inline vacuum degasser should provide you with a way to control the amount of dissolved gas in the solution and reduce drift.

These are a few of the factors which can effect the equilibration and drift times of an HPLC system equipped with a refractive index detector (RID). Careful selection of the instrument module's location, insulating the exposed capillary lines and bottles, optimizing the column and flow cell temperatures, maintaining a steady and controlled temperature in the environment, plus removing dissolved gas from the mobile phase may all contribute to more stable baselines and better quality peak integration. It is also a good idea to review training in the correct operation of the RI detector too. Learning to correctly operate the flush and optional recycle valves on these detectors is critical to their operation. Failure to properly flush the reference cell before each analysis with fresh mobile phase may lead to baseline changes or artifacts.

Another article which may help you improve your analysis method can be found on this site. "Diagnosing & Troubleshooting HPLC Pressure Fluctuation Problems (Unstable Baseline)".

The Three Most Common HPLC Questions and How To Solve Them

The three most common HPLC related questions I am asked each week can be summarized below. Test your basic chromatography knowledge. Before reading the answers, see if you can answer them correctly on your own.

• "What Is Causing the HPLC Baseline, Pressure or Peak Retention Time(s) To: Wander, Change, Drift, Vary or be Unstable?"

• "How Should I Wash or Regenerate My HPLC Column?"

• "How Can I Tell if the Sample is Retained On the HPLC Column? or What Does It Mean When No Chromatography Took Place?"

Let us address each question in order and attempt to provide accurate answers (I have included links after each question to articles with more detailed explanations).

What Is Causing the HPLC Baseline, Pressure or Peak Retention Time(s) To: Wander, Change, Drift, Vary or be Unstable?

• Retention times must be reproducible from run to run.The causes of an unstable baseline and/or changing peak retention time(s) are often related. Common reasons include: Column temperature fluctuations, inadequate mobile phase mixing or degassing, leaks, dirty column, sample overload, lack of pH or buffering control (weakly ionizable samples can be very sensitive to changes). *Full Article link with detailed answers, here.

How Should I Wash or Regenerate My HPLC Column?

Note: Before proceeding with any column regeneration or cleaning procedures, always refer to the specific advice provided by the column manufacturer. Approved maintenance and cleaning instructions can often be found in the product guide or booklet which comes with the new column. Additional information can be found on the vendor's website or by contacting them directly.

• Two issues must be addressed to answer these types of questions. (1) Always wash your column with a specific column wash solution which is stronger than your analysis solution. The use of a stronger solution (In this context, "stronger" means better at dissolving the samples and faster at eluting them from the column) as the wash solution requires regular use to maintain the column. Failure to regularly wash your column may result in compounds accumulating on the column over time (fouling the column) resulting in poor reproducibility, higher back-pressures, contamination and/or poor peak shape. (2) Next, always wash your column after each analysis. This should be a separate step, not incorporated into your analysis method. The analysis method should not include the column re-equilibration steps at all. A second, separate wash method should always follow each analysis method which includes the rinsing of the column with a "stronger" solution for an adequate period of time, then adjustment back to initial conditions where re-equilibration can take place to get it ready for the next analysis run. These are fundamental guidelines of good method development and follow well established principles. Developing methods in this way should increase the lifetime of your columns and improve the reproducibility of results obtained (better %RSD run-to-run).

For more information on washing bound proteins off RP HPLC columns, please refer to this linked article found here.

How Can I Tell if the Sample Is Retained On the HPLC Column? or What Does It Mean When the Sample Comes Out At or Near the Column Void Volume?

• Chromatography is a tool which when used properly adds one or more additional dimensions of physical or chemical characterization information to your analysis data. It does so first by using on-column RETENTION. Samples must be run under conditions which allow the material to interact with the chromatography support for a period of time. We define this time as the retention time. A sample which does not interact at all with the column support material will elute off the column early (and not be retained) at the "column void time" (or column dead time). We refer to this void time as the "T zero" time. When a sample elutes at or near the T zero time, no chromatography has taken place and no method has been developed. It is as if the HPLC column was not used. How do you know what the "T zero" time is (it will be different for different methods)? You must first calculate the HPLC column's dead volume. Once you know the column dead volume and flow rate, you can calculate the T zero time. A scientifically valid HPLC method will include conditions which retain the sample on the column for a long enough period of time to insure that it is interacting with the support. This allows for separation from other compounds to take place and is the purpose of chromatographic resolution. Without this retention mechanism, you are just flow-injecting the sample past the column and skipping all chromatography. It would be far simpler to just place the sample in a spectrophotomer cell as no retention or additional data would be obtained using that technique.

• When first learning liquid chromatography, two of the very first calculations you must learn to use in HPLC are: Column Dead Volume (aka: Column Void Volume) and the K prime of a sample (aka: Peak Capacity Factor). Do you know how to calculate these? They are calculated and reported for each method used. You should be able to tell anyone who asks you what the values are for each method. A chromatographer must know and understand them before using an HPLC system or running a method. They are also critical to method specificity and proper validation. Here are links which after reading and practicing, should make you an expert in these two fundamental calculations. 

"Determination of HPLC Column Dead Volume / Dead Time (T zero)";

"K Prime (also known as: Capacity Factor or Retention Factor): One of the Single Most Important HPLC Parameters of All".

So, how did you do answering these basic questions? If you have put in the needed study time and practical experience to learn and use these fundamentals of high-performance liquid chromatography, then you should have been able to easily provide correct answers to all three questions. If not, then it is time to go back and study up on those basic liquid chromatography texts and article links, plus get more supervised hands-on time with the instruments.

HPLC Retention Time Drift, Change, Area Variability or Poor Reproducibility. Common Reasons for it.

Retention times and area measurements must be reproducible from run to run. When problems are observed, late, early or variable retention times (and/or peak area values) may be observed. Variation outside of acceptable limits indicates a problem with the sample preparation, method design, function of the HPLC system or a lack of training. Here are several commonly observed reasons why sample (or standard) peak retention times or peak area values may not be reproducible:

(1) TEMPERATURE FLUCTUATIONS:

To obtain reproducible results, the temperature of the HPLC column must be kept constant or controlled during each analysis. Laboratory room temperatures can vary up and down by several degrees during the course of one day and these changes will often change the retention characteristics of the sample(s). The 'On' and 'Off' cycling of power from an air conditioner or heating unit will often cause the baseline to drift in a cyclical manner, up and down, during the day (this can often be seen as a clear sine wave pattern when you zoom-in to study the baseline trace over time). Temperature also changes the refractive index of the mobile phase. Optical (Light) based detectors (i.e. UV/VIS, RI...) will show this change as drift up or down). In some cases, a temperature change of plus or minus one degree C from run-to-run can cause changes in retention times which effect reliability of the method. 

To reduce temperature fluctuations, you must control the temperature of the column and mobile phase (if applicable) during the analysis. This is most commonly done by: (a) using fully equilibrated mobile phase at the start of the day or analysis, (b) keeping the interconnecting lines as short as possible (esp. any which exit the column and go to detectors/flow cells), (c) insulating any stainless steel lines with plastic tubing sleeves to reduce heat loss and (d) using a thermostatted column compartment to maintain the column at a single set temperature throughout the day. Control of the column temperature will remove 'temperature' as a variable from your analysis. Method analysis temperature should be constant from run to run, not a variable. Be sure and document the temperature selected as part of your method. 

(2) INADEQUATE MOBILE PHASE MIXING:

Both high pressure (with separate pumps) and low pressure pumping (one pump with a proportioning valve module) systems depend on efficient mixing to accurately meter the requested mobile phase composition. For gradient analysis, failure to completely mix the mobile phase solution before it enters the HPLC column often results in excessive baseline noise, spikes and poor Retention time reproducibility. If your mobile phase composition changes, then the chromatography will change too (e.g. evaporation of the more volatile organic phase from an open bottle may result in a change in composition). "Mixing" is often accomplished directly in a mixer installed in the flow path of an HPLC pump (For more info, please read this article on selecting a mixer). The associated noise and ripple of incomplete mixing can reduce the limit of detection (LOD) and increase integration error. This mixer is often a static mixer (a simple 'Tee', a tube filled with baffles, a frit or beads, valve orifice or microfluidic device) of low volume design for chromatography use, but allows adequate mixing of the liquids within a prescribed flow rate range. The best mixers incorporate longitudinal and radial mixing in-line. A mixer with too low a volume or of insufficient design can result in poor mixing of the mobile phase (note: incorrect solvent compressibility settings can also cause mixing, flow instability and noise problems too). To reduce mixing problems, first insure that the mobile phases used are fully soluble with each other. Next, make sure that any mixer used is appropriate for the flow rates and volumes you will be using. Monitor the baseline for drift, ripple and artifacts in real time to spot problems and make adjustments to correct them. 

(3) INADEQUATE MOBILE PHASE DEGASSING:

For the best results, continuously degass your mobile phase. Reducing the amount of gas in solution will also improve signal to noise levels of detection, reduce Retention time drift and reduce pump cavitation. If you are using an electronic vacuum degassing module, make sure it is maintained and working 100%. A faulty degasser may cause more damage to your system and methods. Maintain and Repair them just as you do for your other instrument modules. Gas bubbles may cause the inlet or outlet check valves to malfunction (get stuck), baseline noise spikes to appear randomly, flow rates and/or back pressure values to become irregular, detector outputs to show high levels of noise (from air in the flow cell) and also cause the loss of prime or cavitation in pumps. To achieve the best balance of low noise levels and high reliability, both aqueous and organic mobile phases should be fully degassed. This can be accomplished through stand alone vacuum degassing modules or through gentle helium gas sparging. In all cases, degassing must be continuous (not just done one time). Continuous degassing reduces cyclical noise and signal variations. For this reason, I do not recommend using ultrasonic baths to degass mobile phase solutions as these are not used continuously. The mobile phase solution starts to re-absorb gas as soon as you stop sonicating the solution. This results in continuous baseline drift.

Removal of gasses is critical to the function of a modern HPLC pumping system. The liquids used are compressed to very high levels which forces out solubilized gas from the solutions. This is best accomplished before the liquid is transferred into the pump. These gas bubbles must be minimized to achieve desirable baselines. *Even if you use a high pressure pumping system, an inline degassing system reduces the amount of noise and baseline drift. Properly maintain and service your degasser to insure compliant operation. IOW: Always degas your mobile phase solutions.

 

(4) SYSTEM LEAKS or FLOW RATE INSTABILITY:

If the peak retention times have increased over time, one possible reason for this change could be a leak. If your flow rate is reduced by a leak, then the retention times will be longer. Always be alert to this pattern of change and check for any signs of leaks on a regular basis. If you find a leak, do not use the HPLC system until it has been repaired. If there is no leak, then the flow rate may not be what you think it is. 

When the actual flow rate is in question, start by checking it manually (never trust the instrument's display screen or the software value for flow rate. Measure it). An easy way to measure the flow rate involves timing the amount of liquid that exits the HPLC detector line after a defined period of time. For example: If your flow rate is set at 1.000 ml/minute, measure the time it takes to fill a 10ml graduated cylinder. It must take exactly 10.00 minutes.

Inadequate degassing, sticking check valves and/or incorrect solvent compressibility values may also cause flow instability.

(5) COLUMN FOULING: 

One of the most common reasons for changes in retention times or area values of well established peak(s) are due to column contamination and fouling of the support material (or of the inlet frit, guard column). The most common reason for this to happen is due to a lack of column flushing or washing after each analysis (esp when running only isocratic methods). Samples that have been poorly prepared, not filtered or were sourced from a complex matrix (i.e. clinical samples) often contain many compounds which are in-addition to the compound of interest. These materials can be retained on the column and not eluted off during each analysis. They build up over time and cause all kinds of strange problems, including changing retention times, new peaks seen and poor overall or wide peak shapes. 

Gradient analysis provides an opportunity to make sure you use a strong enough mobile phase to elute everything off the column during the run. Make sure you ramp up to a high enough concentration of solvent and use a "hold time" to insure this.

Isocratic analysis is a worst case situation for this to occur as the mobile phase is not ramped up to a strong solvent at the end of the method to push off any late eluters, Instead, they accumulate on the column. 

If you use isocratic methods to analyze samples, then you must follow each analysis run with a second, and separate from your analysis method, "column only wash step". This method does not inject any sample. Instead, it uses a strong wash solution which is compatible with your column AND is well known to dissolve any accumulated material into solution and elute it all off the column. For NP applications an alcohol (e.g. MeOH) may be suitable for this job and for RP applications ACN or even MeCl may be be appropriate. Check with the column manufacturer to find out which wash solutions should be used (do not guess, base it on actual sample solubility). 

(6) SAMPLE OVERLOADING (or too large an Injection volume/concentration for the column): If you inject (load) more sample than the column can hold (as determined by a proper loading study), then the peak that results will often be broader in width with more tailing (from diffusion). This will result in a peak which elutes later than expected, fouls the column and results in poor reproducibility.  Be sure to inject the sample dissolved in the mobile phase (or a solution that is weaker than the mobile phase).

(7) SAMPLE INJECTION VOLUME VARIATION: The injection volume used must be appropriate for the type of injector used. All injectors have a stated range in which they are most accurate. Make sure you are injecting within this ideal range and not at the extreme ends of the range (larger error). Manual injectors with fixed loops should be overfilled (3x) for best results. Autosampler vials must be correctly chosen to be compatible with the injector used, contain an excess of liquid and have a loose cap to prevent evaporation or a vacuum from forming inside the vial. *Test injector accuracy and reproducibility separately, at the volume used for your analysis, as part of your method development review. *Review my article on HPLC injectors for more information.

(8) Changes in the pH OF the MOBILE PHASE: Samples containing ionizable compounds are strongly effected by the pH of your mobile phase. Solutions should be prepared fresh, each day (*acids in solvent may change over time). Buffer capacity is often overlooked (the ability to resist pH change). It is highest at the pKa of the acid/base. Try to work within ±1 pH unit of the buffers pKa value for the best pH control of the mobile phase. If your mobile phase is buffered too far away from its pKa, then poor peak shape or variable retention times are often the result. Note: Weakly ionizable samples can be very sensitive to changes of as little as 0.1 pH unit. 

Common Causes of Baseline Noise in HPLC, UHPLC.

Achieving a flat baseline which does not exhibit spikes, ghost peaks, drift or wander in an unpredictable manner should be a primary goal when performing HPLC analysis or developing methods. Methods which result in flat baselines and have well defined, sharp peaks allow for accurate sample area integration. Integration algorithms perform poorly in quantifying peaks on sloped, drifting or noisy baselines. Excessive baseline noise contributes to many problems, including poor quantitation, high %RSD errors, peak identification errors, retention time variation and many other critical problems. Properly developed HPLC methods are reproducible methods which apply and utilize good chromatography fundamentals. Note: "Noise" is a relative term, often w/o meaning. You should always describe it scientifically, measure and compare the signal to noise ration (S/N) of the baseline vs the peak plus note any cyclical patterns (useful in troubleshooting).

Note: A lack of proper training in the operation of the HPLC system, improper start-up or poor quality maintenance of the chromatograph (Examples: failure to degas and purge the system lines before use; poor mixing; an air bubble stuck in a check valve, a bad detector lamp or a leak will often result in baseline noise) are the main causes of noise. Your HPLC system must be optimized for your specific application. Be sure and allow time for the mobile phase to reach full equilibration with the system before starting any analysis. Do not start an analysis until the baseline is stable.

In this article, we will discuss how temperature fluctuations, inadequate mixing, inadequate degassing and flow cell contamination can result in excessive baseline noise. We will provide suggestions on how to reduce or eliminate these problems. Troubleshooting should be done on-site, not over the web or telephone.

TEMPERATURE FLUCTUATIONS:

To obtain reproducible results, the temperature of the HPLC column must be kept constant during each analysis. Laboratory room temperatures often vary by several degrees during the course of one day and these changes will often change the retention characteristics of the sample(s). The 'On' and 'Off' cycling of power from an air conditioner or heating unit will often cause the baseline to drift in a cyclical manner, up and down, during the day (this can often be seen as a clear sine wave pattern when you zoom-in to study the baseline trace over time). Temperature also changes the refractive index of the mobile phase. Light based detectors (UV/VIS, RI...) will show this change as drift up or down). In some cases, a temperature change of plus or minus one degree C from run-to-run can cause changes in retention times which effect reliability of the method. 

To reduce temperature fluctuations, you must control the temperature of the column and mobile phase (if applicable) during the analysis. This is most commonly done by: (a) using equilibrated mobile phase at the start of the day or analysis, (b) keeping the interconnecting lines as short as possible (esp. any which exit the column and go to detectors/flow cells), (c) insulating any stainless steel lines with plastic tubing to reduce heat loss and (d) using a thermostatted column compartment to maintain the column at a single set temperature throughout the day. Control of the column temperature will remove 'temperature' as a variable from your analysis. Temperature should be a constant run to run, not a variable. Be sure and document the temperature selected as part of your method.

INADEQUATE MOBILE PHASE MIXING:

The associated noise and ripple of incomplete mixing can reduce the limit of detection (LOD) and increase integration error. Both high pressure (with separate pumps) and low pressure pumping (one pump with a multi-channel proportioning valve) systems depend on efficient mixing to reduce noise. For gradient analysis, failure to completely mix the mobile phase solution before it enters the HPLC column often results in excessive baseline noise, spikes and poor reproducibility. "Mixing" is often initially accomplished by combining the flow paths of more than one solvent channel together, using a multi-channel gradient valve or tubing. Mixing also performed directly in a mixer installed in the flow path of an HPLC pump. This mixer is often a static mixer (a simple 'Tee', a tube filled with baffles, a frit or beads, valve orifice or microfluidic device) of low volume design for chromatography use, but allows adequate mixing of the liquids within a prescribed flow rate range. The best mixers incorporate longitudinal and radial mixing in-line. A mixer with too low a volume or of insufficient design can result in poor mixing of the mobile phase (note: incorrect solvent compressibility settings can also cause mixing and noise problems too). To reduce mixing problems, first insure that the mobile phases used are fully soluble with each other. Next, make sure that any mixer used is appropriate for the flow rates and volumes you will be using. If needed, run a gradient valve test to insure that each valve channel is working properly, not leaking or introducing any cross-flow leakage to another channel. Monitor the baseline for pressure stability (% ripple), drift and artifacts  (e.g. spikes) in real time to spot problems and make adjustments to correct them. 

INADEQUATE MOBILE PHASE DEGASSING:

For the best results, continuously degas your mobile phase. Reducing the amount of gas will also improve signal to noise levels of detection, reduce drift and reduce pump cavitation. If you are using an electronic vacuum degassing module, make sure it is maintained and working 100%. A faulty degasser may cause more damage (contamination) to your system and methods. Maintain and Repair them just as you do for your other instrument modules. Gas bubbles may cause check valves to malfunction (get stuck), baseline noise spikes to appear randomly, flow rates and/or pressures to become irregular, detector outputs to show high levels of noise (from air in the flow cell) and also cause the loss of prime or cavitation in pumps. To achieve the best balance of low noise levels and high reliability, both aqueous and organic mobile phases should be fully degassed before and during use. This can be accomplished through stand-alone inline vacuum degassing modules or through gentle continuous helium gas sparging (*Helium makes an excellent choice of gas as it is not soluble in the mobile phase. Never use Nitrogen or Argon gas, they are soluble in the liquid!). In all cases, degassing must be continuous (not just done one time). Continuous degassing reduces cyclical noise and signal variations. For this reason, I do not recommend using ultrasonic baths to degas mobile phase solutions as these are not used in a continuous mode. The mobile phase solution starts to re-absorb gas as soon as you stop sonicating the solution. This results in continuous baseline drift (up and down).

Removal of gasses is critical to the function of a modern HPLC pumping system. The liquids used are compressed to very high levels which forces out solubilized gas from the solutions. This is best accomplished before the liquid is transferred into the pump. These gas bubbles must be minimized to achieve desirable baselines. *Even if you use a high pressure pumping system, an inline degassing system reduces the amount of noise and baseline drift. Properly maintain and service your degasser to insure compliant operation. IOW: Whichever method you use, always degas your mobile phase solutions.

FLOW CELLS:

One other less common cause of baseline spikes and random noise is due to either a dirty flow cell (i.e. the windows) or an air bubble trapped inside the flow cell. If the flow cell is suspected of having one of these problems, then it should be carefully rinsed or flushed out with an appropriate mixture of suitable solutions to expel the air bubble or remove the contamination. If possible, keep a spare, 'known good' flow cell on hand to swap out for troubleshooting purposes. This can help to quickly determine where the problem is. This flow cell must be the exact same size and type (volume and path length) for this purpose. If the cell's windows are contaminated and flushing does not restore them, then many manufacturer's offer kits which allow you to replace the windows and gaskets used. Warning: When attempting to clean or repair any flow cell, be sure and work within the manufacturer's operational specifications for the specific flow cell. Some flow cells are not designed to withstand even very low back pressure and damage can result if you exceed their maximum pressure or chemical rating.

Many other types of problems not mentioned in this short article can also cause baseline noise. For example, a sticking inlet or outlet valve on the pump, worn piston seals, worn out detector lamp(s) or detector electrode (EC) can induce noise. In all cases, the cause must be investigated in a logical, step-wise manner. Demonstrate what is working and rule out items one-by-one.

Reference: http://hplctips.blogspot.com/2014/01/diagnosing-troubleshooting-hplc.html