External (ESTD) vs. Internal Standard (ISTD) Calibration in HPLC

Reliable quantitation of sample analytes using HPLC analysis requires accurate and reliable quantitation of a standard(s). For chromatography applications, we commonly use either an External Standard or an Internal Standard, as applicable, to insure reliable quantification of the sample.

• NOTE: A quick comment about calibration methods. Before you begin to create any calibration tables or analyze any standards/samples, please make sure that your current chromatography method follows good chromatography fundamentals. It must be selective for the sample type, retain the compound(s) with good K prime values, be reproducible and resolve apart all of the samples and possible impurities with near to perfectly symmetrical peak shapes. Your calibration results will only be as good as your original method. A poor quality method may not provide reliable results so be sure and spend as much time as possible developing the initial HPLC method to be as rugged and reliable as possible before starting any quantitation or calibration. *Poor quality method development is the number one reason for problems with quantitation.

Methods of Quantitation, Peak-height vs. Peak-area: Both types of response provide a measurement of the detector signal output. Proper and reproducible integration of the signal output is critical. Peak area is the most popular choice in chromatography, but peak height measurements can also be used if the peaks have near perfect symmetry (very rare, so peak area is far more reliable for integration). Whichever method you chose, you must use it consistently and document it well.

Definitions, External & Internal Standards: For most samples, there are two commonly used types of standards used. When known standards are run separately from the actual samples (in their own chromatogram) and their response is compared to that of the sample in another chromatogram, then we refer to this as an External Standard (ESTD). When the standard is added to the sample and analyzed at the same time we refer to this as an Internal Standard (ISTD). With an Internal Standard we are comparing the instrument's response to the sample to a reference standard with similar response characteristics, both run together.

External Standard (ESTD) Calibration Notes: The sample must fall within a range bracketed by the calibration solution. I suggest that you include a range which covers concentration values which are ~ 50% or more outside of the expected range. Dissolve the final calibration standards into the mobile phase (or a weaker solution) when preparing the injection vials from the stock solution. At least five (5) different concentration values should be used per order-of-magnitude (larger range = more stds). *Inject the same volume of solution (different concentration) for each calibration standard point ("level") onto the column. Do Not inject different volumes of solution from one std vial to create different concentrations. Plot peak response vs concentration. Ideally, you should have a linear response and the line will go through the origin (true zero intercept, ideally, though matrix effects/or the use on non std detectors such as the ELSD or CAD may require complex curve fits/formulas to describe the response). Once you have injected all of the standards, repeat the process again at least three more times (or use multiple injections) to determine overall reproducibility before constructing the final calibration table.

Internal Standard (ISTD) Calibration Notes: Internal standards are commonly used when many sample preparation steps are required before the sample can be injected onto the column. The internal standard may compensate for any losses during filtration or extraction. Selection of the Internal Standard is critical. Some of the characteristics of a good ISTD should include: It must be different than the sample, well resolved and must not elute where any sample peaks could be expected; It should not elute where any interfering matrix or other compounds could appear; It should have a similar linear response as the sample (Inject a fixed volume/concentration); Available in a high purity form from one or more commercial sources (certified method); Must be stable and not react with the sample or mobile phase solution. 

Add it to the samples before any extraction procedures. Base the amount of ISTD concentration such that it is between 1/3 and 1/2 of the expected concentration of the sample(s). The sample's target concentration range is a good value to use. *Because of these and other strict conditions, finding a suitable Internal Standard can take some time and testing.

More Windows 7 and XP Tips and Tricks

Transfer Windows Account Settings Utility: 
If you are setting up a new PC or just want to transfer your Windows settings from one computer to another, you may want to take advantage of a Microsoft utility called, "Windows Easy Transfer". It works with both 32 and 64-bit versions of Windows XP, Vista, Windows 7 and 8 and is available in any easy to use utility file. It does not transfer applications. The utility primarily transfers user account data files, folders, photos, music, videos, documents, email messages and contacts plus registry information.

You can download the correct version of the utility from Microsoft's website at this link: http://windows.microsoft.com/en-us/windows7/products/features/windows-easy-transfer

Manually Create a Restore Point (a "backup" point):

To preserve the function of your computer consider manually creating a restore point in the operating system software each time you make an important change or start to install a new program. If something goes wrong during or after the installation process you can restore the computer to a point in time BEFORE you installed the program, which often results in repairing the system. By default, the system automatically creates system restore points, but it does not do so at convenient times (e.g. right before you install new software or make changes to the system). Creating a Restore point is easy. Here are the steps to do so using XP or Windows 7.0
 

 XP 

•   Click on: Start/Programs/Accessories/System Tools/System Restore
•   Click on, "Create a Restore Point".

  7.0

•   Click on: Start/Control Panel/System/System Protection/Create Restore Point

Improve User Login Security by Replacing the Welcome Screen with the User & Password Login Screen:

 7.0  

• By default, Microsoft Windows 7 and 8 default to the Windows "Welcome" screen which allows you to click on various User account icons and enter your password to log on. This feature shows all available user accounts to anyone looking at the monitor. Options exist to hide specific user accounts from the Welcome screen, but a better option is to have Windows start with the User Name/ Password Login screen instead. To switch to the Login screen greeting, run 'Regedit' and modify the policy field as follows (Note: Always back up your registry files and create a new restore point before making any changes to them).
• HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\MICROSOFT\WINDOWS\CURRENTVERSION\POLICIES\SYSTEM . Click on dontdisplaylastusername and modify the key to a value of 1 (to require both the User name and password at login). *Switch the value back to '0' to restore the Welcome screen once again.

Diagnosing & Troubleshooting HPLC Pressure Fluctuation Problems (Unstable Baseline)

Few things in chromatography are more frustrating than dealing with large pressure fluctuations (>1% ripple). If the pump pressure is unstable, and fluctuating up and down, then it will negatively impact your ability to analyze, measure and integrate sample peaks in a reliable manner. A smooth, flat baseline is needed to run and develop methods, collect the data (peaks), integrate and report the results which are reproducible. Baseline instability during an analysis may lead to the entire analysis being declared invalid.

So what causes the HPLC pressure to sometimes fluctuate in a wild manner up and down on your HPLC system? Unfortunately, many things... Most result from poor training, incorrect operation techniques, but some are maintenance related so be sure and keep your chromatograph in excellent condition. Maintain a logbook for each instrument and record what types of maintenance and service have been performed over-time, with the date and list of parts used/replaced. Additionally, maintain a preventative maintenance schedule (e.g. every six months) to inspect and clean the entire HPLC system to check condition, verify operation and minimize unproductive down time. 

HPLC Pump or System Pressure Fluctuation Causes and Solutions:

• Air / gas In the Liquid or Mobile phase (Failure to Degas Mobile phase OR loose fittings) --- Air gets into the system due to a leak or from gas trapped in the mobile phase. Find and correct the cause of the leak and/or degas the mobile phase (use continuous Vacuum degassing or a Helium sparging system only). Leaks are the most common cause of instability, but insufficiently degassed solution is a close second. Make sure your degasser is working 100% correctly (they require professional servicing every 5 years). HPLC pumps require degassed mobile phase for reliable operation.

• Loss of Prime. Improper Priming of the System --- Failure to flush ALL of the lines with freshly degassed mobile phase, before use (every day), will often result in all kinds of instability problems until all of the old gas-filled mobile phase has bee purged from the system. *This could take many column volumes of liquid. Make sure you account for any vacuum chamber volume too. Properly prime the pump heads before use.

• Sticking Check Valve(s) --- If air is exiting the pump outlet, the pump will not function properly. Both Inlet and Outlet valves should be inspected. Remove and clean the check valve(s). Be sure the pump is fully primed with liquid as the check valve might just have an air bubble in it (common on Waters, Thermo and Shimadzu systems). Sometimes sonication of the valve for ten minutes in a beaker containing warm solvent does the trick (e.g. MeOH or IPA/Water). Though very rare, ACN has a bad reputation for polymerizing in solution. If the system has sat unused for a long time OR was not properly flushed out when last used, it is possible that particulate matter may clog the flow path. Small sticky particles may form (ACN polymerization) and cause the check valve to stick inside the housing (use fresh, filtered solvents only to prevent these problems). Clean and inspect any suspect valve first. Replacement of the check valve may be needed in some cases to restore operation. Note, this problem of "sticking" check valves is most likely to be an issue in HPLC pumps with mechanical (gravity or spring) check valves with ruby balls, not modern style active inlet check valves ("AIV") which are electromechanical (solenoid valves) and are very reliable, much less susceptible to these problems. In any case, verify operation of all valves while under pressure (backpressure is needed for them to function correctly).
  

• Worn Pump Piston Seals --- Commonly observed as rapid up/down spiking on all channels and an inability to maintain or produce backpressure (the pump will often prime with no problem, as this is done at low-pressure). Run a formal pump high-pressure leak test at max pressure to confirm (remove the column and replace with a calibrated backpressure restriction line for all testing). Clean pistons and replace piston seals to repair (you should have spare pistons and seals on hand). *Seals are a maintenance item so expect them to wear out and need regular replacement.

• Flow rate too low (may be inappropriate for system). Running at a flow rate that is below the optimum range of the specific instrument (i.e. System rated for 200 to 2,000 uL/min, but run at 100 to 200 uL/min or at the limit of the range) may result in an unstable baseline. The cause may be due to pump cavitation, loss of prime, non-optimized piston stroke volume.

• HPLC System Back-pressure too low to maintain prime in system. Most types of analytical HPLC systems require a minimum system back-pressure of 40 or more bars to maintain enough pressure (mechanical compression) on the component parts to run in a reliable fashion (*Water's Article number: 32564 states the back-pressure must be at least 1000 psi for their Alliance systems). Too low a pressure often results in a loss of prime, cavitation, mixing problems, turbulence and poor reproducibility. Correct sizing of column, particle size, flow rate and mobile phase composition should all take into account achieving enough back-pressure on the system to maintain a stable baseline throughout the entire analysis. Monitor the system back-pressure at all times for stability. High quality research grade HPLC systems are often capable of maintaining stable isocratic flows with less than 1% ripple and 0.2% ripple common ("ripple" is a term we often use to describe the pump's pressure output over time relative to the baseline (S/N)).

• Mixing Problem (gradient or isocratic online mixing) --- If your active mixer or proportioning valve (AKA: Gradient valve) is defective or dirty, then one or more of your mobile phase channels may not be getting to the pump. Air would most likely be mixing with the mobile phase causing the unstable flow. Clean or replace the valve. Note: Always try flushing the gradient valve with pure IPA, then DH20 for about twenty minutes. This sometimes restores operation by wetting and flushing the internal seals (which may dry out).

• Wrong Pump Solvent Compressibility Settings --- In HPLC we routinely subject different liquids to very high pressures which can result in measurable liquid compression. The degree of actual compression for each liquid varies, but the modern HPLC pump can compensate for this to improve the accuracy of the mixing and flow delivery.  Most pumps provide for user adjustable solvent compressibility values. If the value input varies a great deal from the actual liquid in the system, then it can result in pressure fluctuations. Example: Water has a value of 46, but Methanol 120. Using the wrong value can cause instability.  

• Poor Solubility, Mobile Phase  --- Sometimes the mobile phase which has been prepared (or mixed online) is not 100% soluble. This could be due to an inorganic salt additive which has not gone into solution or failure to fully mix and filter the mobile phase before use. Ultrasonication, a bit of heat and stirring for 20 minutes can help to get everything dissolved. 

• Dirty inline filter --- A fouled or partially plugged filter can disrupt the normally smooth flow into a turbulent one. Some are installed as part of the pump (i.e. HP/Agilent brand pumps) and should be changed out every month (Yes, for the PTFE frit, replace it once a month with a new one). Other systems use these pre-filters downstream of the pump before the injector. Clean or replace all filters frequently. If used in your system, these are regular maintenance items and should be part of a general 'PM' program.

• Dirty Solvent Pickup Inlet Filters: These can become obstructed or fouled over time (esp. if used with aqueous solutions!). Just as with any built-in filter, the multiple solvent inlet pickup filters should be cleaned or replaced on a regular basis to prevent particulate or any material which may contaminate or restrict the flow path from entering the system. Mobile phase pickup filters are often 10 to 20 um and connect to the bottom of the low pressure (e.g. Teflon) solvent lines in each bottle. If you use 316 Stainless steel filter (recommended for organic solvents), they should be removed, cleaned in an ultrasonic bath, rinsed and replaced monthly. If you use sintered glass or other disposable type filters (often used with aqueous solutions), they should be disposed of on a regular basis and replaced with new ones (replacement, not cleaning is recommended because sintered glass can not be sonicated and should be disposed of to prevent bacterial, mold or fungal contamination). A quick way to check if one filter is causing the pressure to fluctuate is to remove the filter from the one line, then re-test the system. If the problem goes away, then returns when you re-install the filter back on the line, the filter may be obstructed (replace it),

The above list includes some of the most common reasons for unstable baselines. Other non-pump related causes would include a bad / old detector lamp(s) or contaminated mobile phase. To find the cause, test and verify the operation of each component part of the HPLC. Troubleshooting Advice: Test one part at-a-time, before moving to the next part. Never assume anything, test, re-test and verify or prove at each step.

Two Common HPLC Problems and their Causes (Sudden changes to either the HPLC Backpressure or Peak Shape)

   Let's take a quick look at two different problems which you may encounter when operating an HPLC system. We start with the basic observation and then look at the most likely causes so we can begin the troubleshooting process and repair the problem. An automated HPLC system's flow path typically consists of: The Solvent Pickup Filters (in the mobile phase reservoirs); The Pump(s); AutoSampler; AutoInjector; Column and one or more Detectors.*You should have a good understanding of this flow path before you proceed to diagnose the problem(s).

 *A gradual increase of pressure for the same method over time is often due to column fouling or a dirty inlet frit (e.g. PTFE frit). This article specifically focuses on the causes of a sudden change, not a slow change over time.

   Sudden System Back Pressure Changes: We will assume that you have been running the same method for some time or at least several times without a problem and then suddenly notice that the back pressure has changed from what is normally seen. The problem must lie within the flow path of the system.

   Excessive High Pressure: Typical reasons for this are:

1.      A fouled or plugged column;
2.      Wrong flow rate (higher than normal);
3.      Inlet frit/filter plugged or restricted;
4.      Plugged line;
5.      Wrong mobile phase composition.

   Large Drop in Pressure: Typical reasons for this are:

1.      A leak at a fitting, column or line (Number one reason);
2.      Wrong flow rate (lower than normal);
3.      Wrong mobile phase composition. 

• Start by checking the method parameters to insure that they have not changed (i.e. flow rate, mobile phase composition). Check for leaks or plugs. If the column is suspect, replace it with a zero dead volume union (ZDU) and restrictor and flush the system. Replace the column with a new one or wash the current column according to the column manufacturer's guidelines.

   Sudden Peak Shape Changes: We will again assume that you have been running the same method for some time or at least several times without a problem and then suddenly notice that the peak shape of one or all of the peaks has changed from what is normally seen. *The key thing to keep in mind is that the change occurs all of a sudden, not because of poor initial method development.

   Typical reasons for this are:

1.      Tailing or Split Peaks: Sample overload, change in flow rate, mobile phase composition (e.g. composition or pH), void formation, dirty frit, injection solvent too strong or a fouled column.
2.      Fronting: Commonly seen when overloading sample on column.
3.      Ghost Peaks: Usually due to a contaminated mobile phase, contaminated sample vial or contaminated injector (e.g. rotor seal).
4.      Broad Peaks: Large sample injection volumes or extra column volume (bad connections with the system or tubing) are usually to blame. Try reducing the injection volume by a factor of 10 and see if the problem goes away. You may also want to wash the column as it may be fouled with sample.

   These are just two common problems we see when using HPLC systems. Note that a dirty or fouled column can cause many of these problems so take care of your columns and wash and test them regularly to insure they are in compliance. There are many other commonly seen problems besides these. If you would like to see a specific problem featured on this blog, then please send me a request.