Monday, October 17, 2011

HPLC PUMP SOLVENT COMPRESSIBILITY VALUES

Have you ever noticed excessive pump ripple (baseline noise) that is not caused by a defective check valve ? The ripple might be due to an incorrect HPLC Pump solvent compressibility setting.

We normally think of liquids as not being compressible in general. Hydraulic systems take advantage of this physical fact and many innovations have been developed using this concept. However, in high pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) we routinely subject different liquids to very high pressures which can result in measurable liquid compression. The degree of actual compression varies for each liquid (see table). Though the amount of compression is very small, it is enough to change the flow rate of the system. When multiple solvents are mixed together at different proportions, such as is common when running a gradient, the measured flow rate can vary from the set flow rate during the entire run. This flow rate accuracy issue can be compensated for using the built-in solvent compressibility compensation software which is found in most modern HPLC systems. Many of these systems will allow you to manually enter the actual liquid compressibility values for each solvent (pump channel) used. This can result in better baseline stability and less pump noise. I would like to point out that the small improvement gained in performance is best implemented AFTER other major changes have been addressed first (i.e. such as fully degassing your solvents; filtering samples before injecting; selecting the best signal bandwidth and sampling rate values for your detector and insuring that your pumping system has received regular maintenance). 
 
Note how Water has a compressibility value of ~ 46, but a very common solvent such as Methanol has a value of 120. These two are very different. *Most pumps are pre-set with a compressibility value of '100'. A 50/50 mixture of the two run isocratically might benefit from a manually edited compressibility value of 83 [(46 + 120) = 166 / 2 = 83)]. *This is a best guess value as the best compressibility value for a mixture of liquids must be determined through actual experiments. Choose the value which results in the lowest pump pressure ripple and/or noise. 


SOLVENT COMPRESSIBILITY VALUES TABLE:

Solvent
Compressibility (10-6 per bar)
Water
46
Acetone
126
Acetonitrile
96
Benzene
95
Carbon Tetrachloride
106
Chloroform
100
Cyclohexane
113
Dichloromethane
99
Ethanol
112
Ethyl Acetate
113
Heptane
144
Hexane
158
Isopropanol
100
Methanol
120
Tetrahydrofuran
97
Toluene
90

Notes: 
(1) The values shown above are approximate and assumed to be accurate. They were recorded at a temperature of 20C (Reference: Handbook of Chemistry and Physics #90). Various grades/purity of solvent may have different compressibility values so please verify the values of your own solvents before use. These should serve as a general guideline only.

(2) The variation in pressure which occurs between the pump piston compression and decompression strokes are sometimes reported by the pump's electronics to aid in troubleshooting. Agilent/HP brand systems refer to it as the pressure "ripple" (should be less than 0.5 %) and Waters brand systems report the calculated ratio, "Compression / Decompression Ratio" value using this guideline [1.0 - 1.4 = Normal; 1.4 -1.8 = Fair; > 1.8 = Possible Bubble]. In all cases, continously degass all liquids and input the correct compressibility values for each mobile phase solution to achieve the most stable flow.